Donna Barilla, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson Call or text · (631) 495-6678

Client reviews

What Donna's clients say

4.9 out of 5 stars across 48 Zillow reviews for Donna and her team. A few in their own words:

★★★★★
“She can deliver! Answers queries quickly, any day of the week. Some realtors forget to pitch the close, not Donna. Very reliable and long term client relationship oriented. She has a deep understanding of clients' life circumstances, because buying or selling a house is a very big decision. Building trust and reliability is the first step in this process. Donna gets that.”
Shaikh M. · Bought and sold in Kings Park · Zillow, July 2025
★★★★★
“Donna is an amazing agent to partner with. She helped us find our dream home and held our hand all the way through the process. Met her by accident and we connected right away. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a caring, knowledgeable real estate agent.”
jwakii · Bought a home · Zillow, September 2025
“Donna was a dream to work with!” Alexa O., Zillow“Donna was AMAZING!” delange623, Zillow“Courteous, professional, organized, detail-oriented and caring.” Redfin reviewer, Redfin

Read every review

See all 48 verified reviews on Donna's Zillow profile.

Reviews are reproduced from Zillow and Redfin. Short excerpts are shown where the full review appears on the source site.

Book a time with Donna

Let's grab a coffee and talk.

Tell Donna what's on your mind and when works for you. She'll reply personally, usually the same day.

I'd like to
Best time

Prefer to reach her directly?

Office: Signature Premier Properties, 750 Route 25A, East Setauket, NY 11733

Donna Barilla

How can I help?

Call, text, or pick a time. I reply personally.

Donna's assistant

AI helper · answers questions and books time with Donna

Hi! I'm Donna's assistant. Ask me anything about buying or selling on Long Island, or I can book a time with Donna for you.

I'm an AI, not Donna, and I can make mistakes. Donna confirms every appointment personally. Please don't share financial account details here. Privacy